Outerwear Overhaul: These Are The 23 Best Men’s Pea Coats, Car Coats, Walker Coats, and Overcoats

These Are The 23 Best Men's Pea Coats, Car Coats, Walker Coats, and Overcoats

We've researched the best men's winter coats, based on material composition, product rating, and price.

A Note About Fabric:
High wool counts are always desirable for the quality of cloth, but the inclusion of polyester and synthetic fibers shouldn’t be as much of a turn-off when shopping for winter outerwear as when searching for a suit or clothing for warmer weather. Natural fibers like wool, cotton, silk, and linen are considered better for the environment, but what’s better when considering the wearer himself?

There’s a reason that it’s hard to find reasonably priced outerwear that doesn’t have a composition of at least 25% polyester or other synthetic fibers like nylon or rayon. Polyester is stronger and more flexible than many natural fibers, and its lack of breathability that makes it burdensome in the summer can be a blessing to wearers hoping to retain heat in the winter.

If you’re looking for dressier outerwear like an overcoat to wear with a suit, a higher wool count is desirable. If you’re looking for a durable winter workhorse such as a pea coat or casual walker, don’t let a high polyester count dissuade you.

Continuously updated as we find new ones or old ones go out of stock, rewritten winter 2019.

best men's coats

What's the difference between pea coats, car coats, walker coats, and overcoats?

Generally speaking, these coats are defined by their length and formality:

what's the difference between a pea coat, car coat, walker coat, and overcoat

You'll notice in the product titles below that brands and retailers are inconsistent with the naming convention. Some that are listed as car coats are far longer than traditional ones, and some walker coats are simply titled topcoats. For our purposes, we're organizing them by length.

The Best Pea Coats

The pea coat is a classic cold-weather staple dating back to the 1720s when it warmed the backs of European sailors in harsh weather. Three centuries later, the pea coat retains its venerable double-breasted, short-length design properties but reimagined with a lighter fabric composition that better suits the needs of a modern wearer less prone to taking to the high seas.

Read more about how military uniforms have influenced modern fashion.

Amazon Essentials

Wool-Blend Peacoat

Buy on Amazon for $79

Amazon Rating:
4.2 (35 reviews)

Material:
50% wool, 50% cotton

Color options:
Black, Charcoal, Navy

schott american made wool peac coat

Schott NYC

Classic Melton Wool Peacoat

Buy at Schott NYC for $310

Schott NYC Rating
4.5 (233 reviews)

Material
100% Melton wool

Color options
Black, Navy, Charcoal, Oxford Grey, New Navy, Dark Oxford Grey

nautica

Nautica

Double Breasted Wool Peacoat

Buy on Amazon for $99.89-$193.58

Amazon Rating
4.2 (544 reviews)

Material
52% wool, 40% polyester, 8% other fibers

Color options
Black, Charcoal, Dark navy, Jet black, Comet grey heather, Navy, Carbon

Nick’s Note: Seems like a solid go-to for the budget pea coat shopper.

bgsd peacoat

BGSD

“Mark” Wool Blend Pea Coat

Buy on Amazon for $99.99

Amazon Rating
4.3 (512 reviews)

Material
70% wool, 25% polyester, 5% other fibers

Color options
Black, Navy

marc new york peacoat

Marc New York by Andrew Marc

Burnett Peacoat with Bib

Pick up on Amazon for $89

Amazon Rating
4.5 (12 reviews)

Material
60% wool, 33% polyester, 3% rayon, 2% nylon, 2% acrylic

Color options
Black, charcoal, ink

lands-end-wool-peacoat

Lands' End

Wool Peacoat

Buy on Lands' End for $149.97

LANDS' END Rating
4.1 (68 reviews)

Material
50% wool, 45% polyester, 5% other fibers

Color options
Dark charcoal heather, True navy

The Best Car Coats

If the pea coat originated at sea, the car coat began life inland as a warm outer layer for motorists that soon grew as ubiquitous as cars themselves. The term has been used interchangeably through the last century, but the general modern marketing use refers to a short casual jacket that looks great for a hard day of working in the snow or paired with a cardigan and tie on your way to that evening holiday party.

bgsd car coat

BGSD

Matthew Car Coat

Buy on Amazon for $129.99-$229.99

Amazon Rating:
4.6 (36 reviews)

Material:
70% wool, 25% polyester, 5% other fibers

Color options:
Black

Amazon Essentials

Wool Blend Heavyweight Car Coat

Buy on Amazon for $79

Amazon Rating:
4.4 (33 reviews)

Material:
50% wool, 50% cotton

Color options:
Black, Charcoal, Navy

cole-haan-car-coat

Cole Haan

Classic Coat

Buy on Amazon for $305

Amazon Rating:
4.4 (32 reviews)

Material:
70% wool, 20% nylon, 10% cashmere

Color options:
Black, Camel, Charcoal, Espresso

bonobos-car-coat-best-pea-coats

Bonobos

Slim Fit Water Repellent Wool Blend Car Coat

Buy on Nordstrom for $278

Nordstrom Rating:
N/A

Material:
62% virgin wool, 38% polyamide

Color options:
Textured light gray, Textured navy

vince-camuto-carcoat-best-pea-coats

Vince Camuto

Short Wool Blend Car Coat

Buy on Nordstrom for $105

Nordstrom Rating:
N/A

Material:
62% wool, 33% polyester, 5% other fibers

Color options:
Black, Charcoal, Navy

andrew-marc-bib-jacket-best-pea-coats

Andrew Marc

Mullins Quilted Bib Jacket

Buy on Nordstrom for $99.97

Nordstrom Rating:
N/A

Material:
100% polyester (shell/lining/filling), 100% (bib)

Color options:
Grey, Navy, Olive

The Best Walker Coats

As its name implies, the walker is essentially a short overcoat that ends well above the knee to ease the wearer’s perambulations. Dressier than a car coat, a walker can be worn with a suit, particularly if one commutes to work in the city and needs a practical but warm top layer that won’t get caught in the car door or stuffy on the subway.

best walker coat men

sean-john-peak-lapel-coat-best-walker-coat

Sean John

Wool Coat with Peak Lapel

Pick it up on Amazon for $136.92

Amazon Rating:
5.0 (1 reviews)

Material:
51% wool, 40% polyester, 9% other fibers

Color options:
Camel

tommy hilfiger camel topcoat

Tommy Hilfiger

Barnes Walker Coat

Buy on Amazon for $115.90-$290

Amazon Rating:
4.5 (150 reviews)

Material:
70% wool, 20% nylon, 10% cashmere

Color options:
Black, Camel, Charcoal, Navy

Nick’s Note:
I dig the color options, the reviews, and the partial cashmere composition. One of the better walkers I’ve found.

peter-manning-topcoat

Peter Manning

Fulton Wool Cashmere Topcoat

Buy on Peter Manning for $395

Peter Manning Rating:
5.0 (8 reviews)

Material:
Wool cashmere fabric

Color options:
Charcoal, Camel, Navy, Black

gap-wool-blend-car-coat

Gap

Wool Blend Carcoat

Pick it up on Gap.com for $136

Gap Ratings:
4.5 (30 reviews)

Material:
60% wool, 25% polyester, 10% nylon, 5% other

Color options:
Classic navy blue, classic camel tan, true black

hart-schaffner-marx-windowpane-lapel-coat

Hart Schaffner Marx

Hanover Windowpane Three Button Notch Lapel Coat

Pick it up on Nordstrom Rack for $169.97

Nordstrom Rating:
N/A

Material:
N/A

Color options:
Windowpane charcoal

tommy-hilfiger-addisoon-wool-coat

Tommy Hilfiger

Addison Notch Lapel Wool Blend Coat

Buy on Nordstrom for $169.97

Nordstrom Rating:
N/A

Material:
Wool blend construction

Color options:
Navy plaid

The Best Overcoats

A traditional full-length overcoat is the most appropriate to be worn with a suit, though it can add an elegant – and warm – layer to a dressed-down wool sweater worn with your best jeans and boots. A mostly-wool single-breasted overcoat, knee-length or longer, is a good place to start before graduating to more complex overcoats like the Chesterfield, covert coat, guards coat, or paletot.

jcrew-factory-herringbone-thompson-coat

J.Crew Factory

Wool-blend Herringbone Thompson Topcoat

Pick it up on J.Crew Factory for $159 (final sale)

J.Crew Factory Rating:
N/A

Material:
Wool/poly

Color options:
Blue grey wide herringbone

jcrew-everyday-topcoat

J.Crew

Ludlow Topcoat in Wool-Cashmere

Buy on J.Crew for $200

J.Crew Ratings:
4 (4 reviews)

Material:
Wool/cashmere

Color options:
Navy, Heather charcoal, vintage camel

vince-camuto-carcoat

Vince Camuto

Wool Blend Car Coat

Pick it up on Nordstrom for $122

Vince Camuto Rating:
N/A

Material:
54% wool, 40% polyester, 6% other fibers

Color options:
Black

gap-wool-blend-car-coat

Gap

Wool Blend Car Coat

Pick it up on Gap.com for $228

Gap Rating:
5.0 (1 reviews)

Material:
50% wool, 40% polyester, 10% other fibers

Color options:
Glen plaid

Did you like this guide? Please share it!

This post may contain affiliate links, read about our editorial promise

Nick Guzan is a public relations consultant and writer living in Pittsburgh. He blogs about men's style in movies and TV at BAMFStyle.com. His interests include old movies, muscle cars, maritime disasters, fast food, and single malt Scotch.