Cocktail Class – Essential Techniques: The Stir

Cocktail Class – Essential Techniques: The Stir
Believe it or not, there's more to it than it might seem.

Alex Black is an accomplished bartender at some of Vancouver's most celebrated cocktail bars.

The scene is as old as the bar profession itself: A bartender moving with unmatched poise and intent, meticulously measuring out liquids, letting them cascade on top of one-another in a mixing glass and the moment he or she silently and assertively begins stirring an air of absolute confidence surrounds them as they put the finishing touches on their masterpiece before pouring it elegantly into a glass.

I find few things more impressive than a bartender who can execute the art of stirring properly, it seems almost vulgarly easy.  However there is a proper technique, and I intend to have you utilizing this skill with ease the next time the spotlight is cast upon on you while showcasing your cocktail creation with the appropriate amount of style and ceremony.

We stir to achieve two very simple things: chilling and dilution. There’s a ton of myths surrounding the act of chilling and diluting but fortunately for us there’s the science of thermodynamics to lend a hand. There are lots of fascinating insights into thermal equilibriums and the processes of entropy and enthalpy, but what is essentially happening is the ice you use to mix with is absorbing the heat of the liquid surrounding it, both melting the ice as well as cooling the liquid.

Because spirits and liqueurs are generally soluble with each other, that is to say they blend together easily, it usually only takes a little stir to combine them together indefinitely, the water that is melting into the drink is also soluble and, with a little coaxing from that stir, the ingredients easily form together to make a solution. What we aim to do is fuse the ingredients together, melt the ice and chill the drink and do it in the quickest and quietest way possible, like weaving silk.

cocktail stirring

“Shaken not stirred” is in our cultural vernacular thanks to a famous British spy and I’m here to tell you that the James Bond of the movie world knows women, cars, style and has an enviable wit but he’s a notoriously terrible drinker. Stirring is almost always the preferred way to go, we stir when we have ingredients of similar densities to make a drink but it’s not until we start adding things like syrups, egg whites or juices that we need to move into shaking territory; but more on that next month. Stirring doesn’t aerate the drink like shaking, so it will remain clearer and there won’t be a noticeable change in texture, leaving the drink silkier.

When I started learning bartending, stirring a cocktail was the act of dumping a bunch of liquor over ice and stabbing it with a soda shop-like spoon for 7 seconds then dumping the contents into another glass. But times have changed, that Neolithic practice has evolved and with it a multitude of tools are available for both amateur and professional bartenders alike.

Do you need these tools to execute a proper stir? No. The equipment I like to use behind a bar to stir and strain drinks can cost hundreds of dollars, but I work in an environment where I’m required to execute that act sometimes over a hundred times a night, so my tools need to be durable and ergonomic, you can achieve the same effect for mixing a drink or two at home with items already in your kitchen.

bartender tools - bar spoon mixing glass strainer

Any cylindrical container will substitute fine for a mixing glass (nothing with edges) and a chopstick makes for an excellent stirring stick, so much so it’s the preferred tool for one of my favourite barmen, proving the barspoon is the golf ball of the bartending world.

The Drink: The Manhattan

If we’re talking classics, it doesn’t get much more classic than this one. Already a popular tipple by the 1880’s the drink’s first appearance in a cocktail book came in O.H. Byron's 1884 book, The Modern Bartenders' Guide. The drink’s history is a bit murky but as best we can tell it was invented by a bartender in New York who simply went as ‘Black’.

What you’ll need:

  • 2 oz. of a decent whiskey, I prefer rye but you can go the bourbon route if you wish (suggested: Smooth Ambler Old Scout Rye or Rittenhouse)
  • ¾ oz. of a decent sweet vermouth, or maybe a blend of two (suggested: Carpano Antica Formula)
  • 4 dashes of bitters (suggested: Scrappy’s Orange or Aromatic)
  • A mixing glass (or a reasonable substitute)
  • A barspoon (or chopstick)
  • A strainer (or any method to keep the ice in the glass and get the liquid out)
  • Ice (the clearer and denser the better – more on this in my next piece, so stay tuned!)

1. Take your mixing glass and add your whiskey, sweet vermouth and bitters into it.

2. Place your barspoon in the glass THEN add ice. This prevents ice from breaking off by stabbing the spoon through it if done reversed, also makes it look like you’ve done this before.

cocktail ice cube

3. Lightly grip the base of your mixing glass with two fingers of one hand, keeping in mind not to transfer any body heat from your hand to the glass which may lead to over-dilution.

How to stir a cocktail

4. With your free hand pinch the spoon loosely between two fingers, here you’re simply creating a pivot point so you shouldn’t need much grip on the spoon. Gently, yet swiftly, push and pull the spoon forwards and back while guiding the base in the glass around the circumference of the mixing glass.

  • Your hand should stay relaxed and not move much at all, all the movement should be in the two fingers touching the spoon and a bit in the wrist.
  • The real challenge to this is making sure the drink is stirred with minimal (read: no) noise. Noise means the ice is bashing into itself and the glass creating tiny shards that can over-dilute and aerate your drink.

5. Stir as long as you want depending on how cold and diluted you want your drink to be, feel free to test along the way to see what’s right for you. A good window would be 10-30 seconds which would leave the drink around 5°C/41°F – 0°C/32°F. After 2 minutes you could theoretically get the drink down to -6.75°C/19.8°F but after that the temperature would stabilise and not get much lower.

  • You don’t want to water down the drink, but you don’t want to make it so harsh it’s not enjoyable, find your sweet spot and keep in mind cocktails with heavier ratios of water tend to be more aromatic

Straining a cocktail

6. Strain the now finished, perfectly chilled and diluted cocktail into a chilled cocktail glass, feel free to garnish with an orange zest or brandied cherry (I’d stay away from anything so red it would better suit a clowns face than a cocktail).

cocktail cherry

7. What’s that you say? You’d like yours on the rocks? That’s fine, although the aromas that open up on this cocktail can be amazing when it starts to warm a little. Just keep in mind that your dilution will continue to go down if it’s served on ice so try under-diluting it while stirring so you don’t end up with a glass full of Manhattan flavoured water halfway through the drink.

8. Drink, enjoy & be merry.


how to make a manhattan cocktail

Alex Black has honed his skills in hospitality and bartending for over 15 years, and has integrated himself into Vancouver's world class hospitality community including top tier locations under the Donnelly and Glowbal umbrellas as well as Hawksworth, Boulevard, the famous Gerard Room in the Sutton Place Hotel and the Vancouver Club. He has been a part of some of the Pacific Northwest’s most prized bar programs and events, amassing a number of certifications and personal awards. Read more on his website.


  • Reply February 25, 2016

    Jeff Parker

    I just want to commend you on a very well thought out and informative post. I am a culinary professional, but have never really delved much into the methodology of mixology (other than ordering a cocktail). I learned some stuff… Cheers! Looking forward to your next post.

    • Reply February 25, 2016

      Alex Black


      Thanks for the feedback. Looking forward to hearing your comments on future articles

  • Reply February 25, 2016

    S. Newman

    what kind of cocktail glass is that/ is it available online?

    • Reply February 25, 2016

      Alex Black

      I don’t know if there’s an exact term for the glass used. It’s a classic cocktail glass that maybe would fall into the definition of a “Nick and Nora” glass. I found my set of four at a local vintage shop

  • Reply February 25, 2016


    So I don’t make a lot of cocktails at home, I’m more of a craft beer guy. But when I do, one of my favorite is the Americano (Campari, Vermouth, & soda). I’ve always just put ice in the drinking glass, poured the liquers in, added soda & stirred. To use this method it sounds like what I should do is mix the campari & vermouth in a seperate glass with ice, then pour it over ice into the drinking glass and top off with soda? Am I right on that?

    • Reply February 27, 2016

      Alex Black


      The Americano is one of my favourites too, no need to complicate that one. I’d stick to building them just the way you are, it’s exactly how I make mine at home.

      • Reply February 27, 2016


        Thanks fir the advice. Most people are familiar with the Negroni but I’m not a big gin fan so I prefer the Americano.

  • Reply February 26, 2016


    I love a good Manhattan. Though a couple of them can knock me on my _ss.

  • Reply February 26, 2016

    Justin Tessier

    Thanks for this. I’m going to be in Vancouver soon for work. Would love to stop by for a drink. Where can I find you?

    • Reply February 27, 2016

      Alex Black


      I’m working on a new project right now. Doors will be open in April but we’re holding off on announcements for a few weeks. I’d love to host you if the timeline works out. If not I’d gladly recommend a few great spots you should stop and enjoy a drink at.

      • Reply February 29, 2016

        Justin Tessier

        Damn. I’ll be leaving just before you open.

        When in town, I usually hit Diamond and L’Abattoir. If you have other suggestions or a recommended drink at those spots, let me know!

        • Reply February 29, 2016

          Alex Black

          Both great spots. Hawksworth, Anna Lena, Supermarine, the Keefer and Notturno are some of my favourites

          • March 3, 2016

            Justin Tessier

            Great! Thanks, and good luck with your endeavour.

      • Reply April 12, 2016

        Justin Tessier

        Revisiting this since I’m back in the city quicker than I thought!

        If you’ve opened, I’d love to hear more about it and swing by.

        • Reply April 13, 2016

          Alex Black

          We’re not open as of yet. Waiting on government inspections. I would offer to show you around but in the mean time I’ll be in Sweden getting some hands on training at the Absolut distillery.

  • Reply March 7, 2016


    In the last couple of weeks we’ve seen an array of dope custom sneakers, most noticeably using the Nike Kyrie 1 as the silhouette of choice. Some of nike jordan air the best have been the “Watch The Throne” and the “2K14″ colorways that were both originally seen on past LeBron silhouettes.Kobe’s final season is slowly but surely coming to an end as the regular kobe 10 high top season will be ending in mid-April. That means that Kobe has about seven weeks left in what has been a hell of a career for one of the greatest of all-time. So how can Nike nike air max one make it better?In addition, the commemorative range pulls inspiration from the courage and determination of six athletes/coaches: Theotis Beasley (Skateboarding), Kevin-Prince Boateng (Soccer), Jerry Rice (Football), Brianna Rollins (Track and Field), C. Vivian Stringer new balance 800 (Basketball) and John Thompson (Basketball).Since the Black Mamba missed a large portion of last season, we didn’t get to see him wear the Kobe 10 as much as some people hoped. That all changes Cheap Kobe 10(X) now as Kobe has already been spotted wearing some PE colorways of his 10th signature sneaker with Nike during the preseason. Up above we get a look at a “Home” Lakers colorway that he may nike air huarache run or may not be lacing up at some point this season. This Nike Kobe 10 Elite features a white flyknit upper with purple detailing on the translucent midsole and the Nike check on the side air max one panels. Gold outlining on the Swoosh and a translucent outsole wrap things stephen curry writing on shoes up.The Nike Kobe 11 Brave Blue is scheduled to release on April 14th for $200. What are your thoughts on this colorway?President Barack Obama, our Commander in Chief, receives a special homage with the latest Nike Kobe 10 Elite, appropriately dubbed “Commander.”

Leave a Reply