I've never been very impressed with the one's I've tried until I checked out Bespoke Post's "Box of Awesome". For $45 a month, Bespoke Post sends you a themed box, with past boxes including shoe care kits, coffee-making gadgets, and the one pictured here, a full set of bar tools required for every budding mixologist.
The boxes contain items worth over $70, and the ones in my bar set are high quality, restaurant-grade tools.
Bespoke Post knows guys so well, they incorporated our fear of commitment right into the service: skip a box any time if it doesn't seem "awesome" to you.
Check it out at www.bespokepost.com.